BWFiles

The Archive => Archived Boards => Godus General Discussion => Topic started by: Gremxula on Jan 05, 2013, 10:56 pm

Title: Godus V From Dust
Post by: Gremxula on Jan 05, 2013, 10:56 pm
Both claim to be Populous inspired.
What do you think....?
I will post my opinions later.... to be fair  I have played  From Dust for a few levels and abandoned it.
Godus..... Nothing to play yet but  the published  graphics and game-play videos leave a lot to be desired.
Title: Re: Godus V From Dust
Post by: Sylcai on Jan 06, 2013, 06:39 pm
I played from dust from begin to end. It eventually came down to more of a puzzle game. - never did get past the second time trial.

Godus.. well... still a bit early to decide on that.
Title: Re: Godus V From Dust
Post by: fenton_pat on Jan 07, 2013, 10:58 am
Played a few levels of From Dust myself and while it looked awesome, there just didn't seem to be that much game to me :( .

For all your abilities, you had to play each land in pretty much an exact way to get your guys through it.  It was pretty much Lemmings 3D with Awesome graphics :laugh2 !

For Godus to get me smiling, it has to do that trickiest of things - have a decent storyline from which good sandbox functionality can hang off of.

And here's where I start to worry...

While I don't put too much weight on the prototype they developed, I worry about the depth of gameplay Godus will have from what I saw so far.  Apparently, the game will also work on mobile platforms with the only major difference being graphical quality.

This makes me wonder - how can a game that runs on both mobiles and on PC manage to have appropriate levels of gameplay depth on both? 

From Dust looked awesome.  But at the end of the day, it could have easily featured on a phone or tablet (graphics not withstanding).

Granted, given time and money, there seems to be no better man than PM to create a game where there are simplistic controls for accessing a lot of features, but until we see more in this regard, this will be my biggest concern moving forward :suspect .
Title: Re: Godus V From Dust
Post by: Gremxula on Jan 19, 2013, 09:09 pm
OK..... I delayed my response just to go over  my old RTS games that I still had installed.

At the moment Godus seems to be a bit to simplistic to be of any interest for me.

It took years to develop games  like Populous  1.2&3  B&W 1&2  Fable ...... with P Mx

Now a game that has a budget  for a few weeks development.......is it really  going to be a proper PC game?

I doubt it..... I can see it  as  a phone app.....  but not  as  a serious  PC game.
 Just not enough time or money. :(
 
Title: Re: Godus V From Dust
Post by: Exit2008 on Jan 21, 2013, 08:06 am
In my opinion, there is only one way godus would end up any better than those browser godgames. If they where t pick up he model minecraft used namely selling a playable game as they develop it, godus might just make it. Still i think a number of people beyond that have to screw up, for the game to end like from dust. which i forced my way trough in whirling pain.
In the end any god game is a good change, even if its simple.  :cool:
Title: Re: Godus V From Dust
Post by: Gremxula on Feb 03, 2013, 05:35 pm
I have to admit I never  had the will to finish From Dust, but I had to try it as it was billed as a "spiritual" successor to Populous.
Title: Re: Godus V From Dust
Post by: WhatsHisFace on Apr 10, 2016, 04:21 pm
After the debacles over "Godus," my lack of enthusiasm has prevented me from getting around to playing it.

However, I can speak on "From Dust," which I enjoyed every minute of.

While it was not truly a "god game" proper, the title did have a lot of elements that scratched the old god game itch. Being in full control over the landscape and seeing the engine process and render these complex effects in real time was a true sight to behold. I picked this game up because of it's visual similarities to "Black and White," and if there ever were to be a third one (or an ambitious spiritual successor), I believe taking some points from "From Dust" could really make it the most complete god game out there.